Search Results

1. Identifying & responding to bias in the criminal justice system: a review of international & New Zealand research [pdf, 1.3 MB]

   ...an overview of race and crime literature 31 Explaining disparities 31 Structure of Part 1 32 Policing 32 Stop and search 33 Arrest decisions 37 Charge management 40 Court processes 42 Prosecution 43 Sentencing 44 Legal representation 47 Plea decisions 47 Bail 48 Mode of trial 50 Pre-sentence reports 51 Sentencing decisions in New Zealand 53 Prison 53 Parole 54 Methodological issues 56 Summary 58 6 Identifying and responding to bias in the criminal justice system...

2. Canterbury Westland Standards Committee v Horsley [2014] NZLCDT 47 [pdf, 85 KB]

   ...to having a previously unblemished career he has contributed to his profession in terms of continuing legal education and committee work for the Law Society. He is certainly deserving of credit for all of these matters. [36] As to his guilty plea on the second charge, he ought to receive some credit for that but it came very late in the piece, on the morning of the first hearing. [37] The acceptance of responsibility by the practitioner and the mitigating features referred to are...

3. CAC20003 v Santipongchai [2015] NZREADT 11 [pdf, 177 KB]

   ...licensee to be a present licensee for the purposes of our sentencing for proof of misconduct”. Outcome [23] We agree with Mr Hodge’s said submissions on behalf of the prosecution. We take into account the defendant’s remorse and early plea of guilty and his apparent good intentions of rehabilitation. However, he must be firmly penalised, although a fine and costs orders seem futile due to the defendant being bankrupt. [24] In all the circumstances, we order cancellation o...

4. Complaints Assessment Committee 408 v Reed [2017] NZREADT 34 [pdf, 160 KB]

   ...Ms Dai had pleaded guilty to three charges of wilful or reckless breach of the Rules. One of these involved disclosing her client’s price expectations to a purchaser. The Tribunal did not impose a fine, referring to Ms Dai’s early guilty pleas, her voluntary suspension of her licence, relative inexperience, and her inability to pay a fine. [30] We accept Ms Copeland’s submission that the facts in Dai are closest to the present case, but they are not directly comparable. Mr...

5. WVU v Real Estate Agents Authority Jurisdiction Objection [2014] NZHRRT 49 [pdf, 56 KB]

   ...person Ms K Lawson-Bradshaw for first defendant Mr J Burns for second defendant DATE OF DECISION: 10 October 2014 DECISION OF TRIBUNAL ON JURISDICTION OBJECTION BY SECOND DEFENDANT Background [1] In 2013 the plaintiff entered a plea of guilty to a charge of misconduct brought before the Real Estate Agents Disciplinary Tribunal under s 73(a) of the Real Estate Agents Act 2008. As a consequence he was fined $1,500 and his licence cancelled for six months. 2 See...

6. Auckland Standards Committee 1 v Hanif [2019] NZLCDT 13 [pdf, 156 KB]

   ...appeared to be under the misapprehension that these proceedings involved a de novo hearing of the merits of the criminal prosecution. However, in the course of answering questions in cross-examination, Mr Hanif admitted the charge and, this change of plea having been clarified by the Tribunal with the practitioner directly, the matter proceeded on a penalty only basis. Legal Framework [4] Section 241(d) reads: 241 Charges that may brought before Disciplinary Tribunal If the Dis...

7. NZ BORA Advice: Land Transport Clean Vehicles Amendment Bill [pdf, 214 KB]

   ...requirement to supply the information under new 197B of the Bill. Sections 54 to 57 relate to privilege for communications with legal advisers, solicitors’ trust accounts, preparatory materials for proceedings, and settlement negotiations, mediation, or plea discussions. 15 Unless the court hearing the proceeding in which the evidence is sought to be adduced is satisfied that there was no unfairness in obtaining the evidence (proposed s 197G(4) of the Land Transport Act 1998)....

8. People charged and convicted of harmful digital communication offences December 2021 [xlsx, 172 KB]

   ...2021 Table 2: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by court and charge outcome, 2015 - 2021 Table 3: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by plea type, 2015 - 2021 Table 4: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by gender, ethnicity and age group, 2015 - 2021 Table 5: Number and percentage of people convicted of Harmful Digital Comm...

9. People charged and convicted of harmful digital communication offences June 2022 [xlsx, 172 KB]

   ...Table 2: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by court and charge outcome, 2015/2016 - 2021/2022 Table 3: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by plea type, 2015/2016 - 2021/2022 Table 4: Number and percentage of people charged with Harmful Digital Communications Act offences, by gender, ethnicity and age group, 2015/2016 - 2021/2022 Table 5: Number and percentage of people convicte...

10. Environment Court annual review 2015 [pdf, 2.4 MB]

    Environment Court of New Zealand Annual Review Calendar Year 2015 By Members of the Court Environment Court of New Zealand Annual Review 2015 2 PUBLISHED MAY 2016 CONCERNING CALENDAR YEAR 2015 In this review Calendar year 2015: an overview by Principal Environment Judge ........................................ 4 Profile of the Court ........................................................................................................