Establishing a Criminal Cases Review Commission [pdf, 395 KB]
...Further, judicial review actions of decisions made by the UK CCRC and the Scottish CCRC have been rare. Decisions from judicial review cases against the CCRCs in both Scotland and the UK have emphasised that the courts are hesitant to override the CCRC judgement on a case.23 Even if the court objects to a decision to not refer a case by the CCRC on the merits, they have tended to rule on whether the decision was legally tenable and, if not, that the CCRC should reconsider the case. Legal...